So: Dumbledore is referring to his last letter, which means, of course, the letter he left upon the Dursleys' doorstep when Harry was one year old. What law that took effect in roughly the last year changed nutritional information requirements for restaurants and cafes? - Quora Something went wrong. Featured image courtesy of HuffingtonPost. Why not just send him off? She had done bad things, but the hints that she had cared for her sister (and even Harry, in a way) implied that she could have found some redemption. His only source of information came from Petunia, who loathed the wizarding world, and . A brief history of TV shows replacing actors - ABC News We earn a commission for products purchased through some links in this article. She sank into the chair beside Dudley, her face in her hands. He probably would have tried to find out where Harry went when he was away from Hogwarts, and the Ministry certainly knew where Harry was and with whom. It seems that Arthur Weasley and Kingsley Shacklebolt (and probably others in the Order of the Phoenix) believed that Voldemort would be able to get at Harry when he turns seventeen and the protective charm that Dumbledore put on the house would break. >J.K Rowling Has Called Out A Classic Gryffindor Character After He Publicly Defected To Slytherin! Harry Potter. "We have a witch in the family. This theory first came about way back in 2004 before JK . Maybe, just maybe, more of them were Petunia's fault than the reader was initially led to believe. Aunt Petunia is wearing a very short dress and invites Harry to join her on the couch. Wait, was Harry Potter's Aunt Petunia actually a witch? I think Dumbedore did something, like making sure Petunia can't have more children for example, in case she gave Harry to an orphanage or did something Dumbeldore did not want. So what if Petunia Dursley, aka Aunt Petunia, isnt actually a Muggle but a witch who suppressed her powers after being rejected by the wizarding world? She is not a Squib, although that is a very good guess. A life of living in her sisters magical shadow. Petunia Dursley (ne Evans) (pre 1960 - pre 2020) was an English Muggle woman, the elder daughter of Mr and Mrs Evans and the older sister of the Muggle-born witch Lily Potter. What if she'd looked back and said the thing she wanted to say? It also explains how she knew what Dementors and Azkaban were despite very little contact with her sister or Harry. Brought to you by Wizarding World Digital, a partnership between Warner Bros. and Pottermore. She has a suprising knowledge of magic, which means that she was really just trying to protect her family from it. Why would she have had to be related to James in particular to be a Squib? But you will have to read the other books. That presumably included him not turning out a "freak" like his father and mother. Petunia had also buried deep inside her (and never confessed to Vernon) her long ago hope that she, too, would show signs of magic, and be spirited off to Hogwarts. relatives MORE : This man made his wife a real-life Harry Potter Pensieve filled with all their happy memories together, MORE : Daniel Radcliffe says hes barely spent any of his Harry Potter fortune, Arsenal star Declan Rice makes joke about Moises Caicedos transfer to Chelsea, Arsenal boss Mikel Arteta explains decision to bench Gabriel Magalhaes again and responds to exit rumours, Woman fined for fighting back too much during sex attack, Sandra Bullock to scatter Bryan Randalls ashes in Bahamas after partners death at 57, Emmerdale spoilers: Charitys new love interest confirmed and youll be stunned, Harry possibly being able to speak to dragons, http://sulietsexual.tumblr.com/post/95271038401/you-might-have-got-the-impression-that-there-is-a, This man made his wife a real-life Harry Potter Pensieve filled with all their happy memories together, Daniel Radcliffe says hes barely spent any of his Harry Potter fortune, Do not sell or share my personal information. While Snape doesnt mention the Dursleys or Privet Drive by name, he does imply that he (or Voldemort already) knows the location. Were all about Harry Potter fan theories. It explains about Lily's passing and the circumstances that protect Harry and the Dursleys while he lives with them. Alas, we will never know. @Mindwin Back when Lily was accepted, Petunia had written a letter to Dumbledore asking for admission to Hogwarts. Her days as a Dursley may seem picturesque, but deep down, Petunia is constantlyfighting the urge to (as Dumbledore so eloquently puts it) do what is right instead of what is easy. Instead, Harry only subtly realized how Petunia felt and never said anything to her about it or took the time to forgive her. All he knew was that he was not the only person in the room who had an inkling of what Lord Voldemort being back might mean. Therefore, there was no easy way for the Harry Potter movies to include Petunia's complex story since a character explaining it to the audience just wouldn't have worked. There's some good questions in here, but it might help to break some of them out into separate questions (i.e. When did Dumbledore correspond with Aunt Petunia? Could be referring to the fact that her other nephew is a. She remembers "that awful boy" (meaning James Potter) mentioning Dementors being the guards of Azkaban, the wizard prison. Erm, no, youre actually being SO DISCREET BECAUSE WE HAVE NO IDEA WHAT IS GOING ON. She constantly made Harrys life difficult, made him live in a cupboard, and consistently treated him like crap compared to her beloved son, Dudley. (Remember my last? Apparently I haven't "found out what it is". Bustle originally found the post on Tumblr, which actually dates back to 2014, . "You might have got the impression that there is a little bit more to Aunt Petunia than meets the eye, and you will find out what it is. Aunt Petunia, as we all know, was a pain. Oh, I am giving a lot away here. Which would be to protect Harry. Number four, Privet Drive might be the most relentlessly non-magical environment in the Harry Potter books but the wiper of its pristine surfaces had a surprising secret. Good question. But, thanks to the memories of Severus Snape, we know that Petunia once held different aspirations. 2023 BDG Media, Inc. All rights reserved. In Ravenglass they're met by Martha, a professional psychic who resembles "a fairy-tale witch." Aunt Martha acts as caretaker for Hobbie House but keeps her own apartment in town, where she . Aunt Petunia, whose face had been buried in her handkerchief, looked around at the sound. View 0 thoughts swirling around the pensieve. find unless, of course, the Secret Keeper chooses to divulge it. If he finds anyone who isn't a pureblood wizard to be unworthy of his notice, then a muggle probably wouldn't be worth his time. When Harry and the others left, the Death Eaters were waiting. The truth is, Petunia holds a grudge against her sister because she's jealous. Dumbledore sent the Howler. There's a fan theory that suggests that Aunt Petunia - HelloGiggles It can't be dumbledore who sent the howler because Harry asks himself who's terrible voice it could be.. Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience. What was in the letter to the Dursleys Dumbledore left with baby Harry? To conclude: Another theory, another reminder that Harry Potter will be messing with our brains for the rest of our lives. She is a Muggle, but You will have to read the other books. Vernon had no idea who this was, but Petunia immediately became terrified. Maybe Aunt Petunia had some "pick me girl" going on. The two couples just could not find common ground, and while Lily wanted James to make things right with Vernon, it never happened. However not all the family feeling was gone: Petunia sent Lily at least one Christmas present a horrible vasewhich baby Harry broke as he flew around on his miniature broom that Sirius Black sent him for his first birthday (DH10). By clicking Accept all cookies, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. She resented Harry so much because he was a sign of the magical world that she couldn't get rid of. I am in the middle of rereading the books, and was wondering this again. In Deathly Hallows, Harry states that the Dursleys should go into hiding because Voldemort might try to take them hostage to make Harry come and save them, so the Order itself takes it upon themselves to ensure the Dursleys' protection. It would have been right for her to treat him like a second son, but as audiences see, that isn't something that comes easy. How to cut team building from retrospective meetings? She actually wanted to be a witch at one point, which is proven when the Pensieve reveals that Petunia wrote to him asking if she could attend Hogwarts. So i thought maybe this wasn't the first time the discussion of keeping harry came up in the house. You have a lot of votes, and you have some good quotes, but being Lily's sister, and possessing human emotions hardly qualifies as "more than meets the eye". For some reason, Petunia Dursley felt inclined to keep it forall these years. They couldve bonded over their mutual interests in garish tea sets. Is Aunt Petunia A Witch? - Stellina Marfa No, Petunia was never a nice person, but fate wasn't exactly nice to her, either which is why this fan theory that Aunt Petunia was a witch, or at the very least had magical inclinations, makes a lot more sense than most. The information is hidden inside At this moment, Harry realized that the magical world was more to Petunia than just a group of people . Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, and our products. Petunia had written to Dumbledore when Lily was admitted to Hogwarts. Wanted: Have You Seen this Narnia Villain? AND family Magical sibling rivalry a freak! She's horse-faced and extremely nosy; her favorite pastime is spying on the neighbors. However, while the movies made her nothing more than a villain, the books demonstrated how even someone as despicable as Patunia is more complex than that. I think this more humane side of petunia is what's being referred to here. What did the Howler to Aunt Petunia mean in Order of the Phoenix? Its mentioned later in the book, as well as in some of the other answers. . Kemi Rodgers We would like to show you a description here but the site won't allow us. HARRY POTTER, characters, names, and all related indicia are trademarks of Warner Bros. 2001 2023. Of course, as the series continued, this trope was flipped by the subtle hints revealing that Petunia cared more for her sister than she used to claim. I believe she wanted harry to know that she wasn't entirely heartless, that she regretted her treatment of him, but she couldn't. Not only that, but Petunia and Vernon both encourage their own family members, particularly Aunt Marge, to treat Harry the same way. rev2023.8.21.43589. Do any two connected spaces have a continuous surjection between them? 'We have a witch in the family! However, she did burst into tears when Dudley said Harry wasnt a waste of space after all. EDINBURGH BOOK FESTIVAL - AUGUST 15, 2004 - BLOOMSBURY. Hang on, was Harry Potter's Aunt Petunia actually a witch all along? But there was another occasion when Albus had a reason to write, and it had long-lasting consequences. Rules about listening to music, games or movies without headphones in airplanes, Legend hide/show layers not working in PyQGIS standalone app. She ultimately deals with these emotions by becoming the bitter magic-hating woman that she is. Unleash chocolate frog bedlam within the castle walls? Why would you think that? RELATED:Harry Potter: 10 Hidden Details About House Elves You Probably Missed. How do I know how big my duty-free allowance is when returning to the USA as a citizen? The Thing frequently boasts of being "Aunt Petunia's favorite nephew," so unlike Petunia Dursley, this character doesn't seem to be harsh or contemptuous to her nephew. Aunt Petunia hated animals. If Lily and Petunia's parents had been magical, she would have been a Squib, with no closer relationship to James than she already has. By clicking Post Your Answer, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge that you have read and understand our privacy policy and code of conduct. She was also able to contact Hogwarts, since she wrote a letter to Dumbledore when she was very young. Before she became the Marigolds-wearing Mrs Dursley we know and loathe, Petunia Evans or Tuney as her sister called her actually longed to be a witch. Plus, who remembers this deleted scene from the movie?! When Petunia blurted out a competent description of a Dementor, Harry was more surprised than Uncle Vernon to hear her speak of Azkaban. WIZARDING WORLD Publishing and Theatrical Stage Rights J.K. Rowling. All for Lily. In stark contrast to her overindulgence of her own child, Harry is treated like an unwanted servant, forced to cook, clean and do all the work in the garden (CS2). She gave him an odd, tremulous look and seemed to teeter on the edge of speech, but then, with a little jerk of her head, she bustled out of the room after her husband and son. @Radhil That's what I've always assumed as well. Uncharacteristically, she also agreed to Dumbledore's written request to take Harry in when he was orphaned ( PS1 ). The latter of which is referencing Aunt Petunia's relentless need to peer through the curtains to spy on (and gossip about) her neighbors. Maybe "remember my last" meant remember my last dying wish? During her final parting with Harry, she stopped for a moment, as if to say something. from Harry Potter and the Sacred Text, Consciously Rejecting the Magic The Cases of Susan Pevensie and Petunia Dursley by Mcineanu Laura, Tags: Aunt Petunia, as we all know, was a pain. I count six different questions in your post on different topics. JK Rowling reveals why the Dursleys dislike Harry Potter so much You might have got the impression that there is a little bit more to Aunt Petunia than meets the eye, and you will find out what it is. Her large, pale eyes (so unlike her sisters) were not narrowed in dislike or anger: They were wide and fearful. Petunia tries to avoid the wizarding world at all costs. YOU WILL OBEY! Aunt Petunia was a witch all along according to a new Harry Potter fan theory From the first Harry Potter book and film, Mrs Dursley has been spitefully ashamed that her sister Lily, Harry's. Wizarding World is the new official home of Harry Potter & Fantastic Beasts. She briefly sees Ron in Harry's second year, during his infamous escape, and even Dumbledore drops in for a visit later down the line. Looking for Pottermore? Weve seen Petunia revel in horror at the mention and sight of magic and even the fact that her sister was a witch. Echoes of the Past: Street Names in Little Whinging, Surrey:Showing the Location of Little Whinging (on the scene investigation by Nik the Hermit), Consciously Rejecting the Magic The Cases of Susan Pevensie and Petunia Dursley. Petunia was proud. A muggle, Petunia is terrified of magic and participated fully in Vernon's project of bullying Harry. Since Harry has known dumbledore for 4 years now he had to recognize his voice, no matter how much more 'terrible' than normal. "We have a witch in the family. the chosen person, or Secret Keeper, and is henceforth impossible to Harry Potter: 10 Things You Didn't Know About Petunia Dursley I have searched around at least a reasonable amount and I have no idea what about Aunt Petunia is more than meets the eye. Oh, I am giving a lot away here. She stopped and looked back. She knows that allowing you houseroom may well have kept you alive for the past fifteen years.. Running fiber and rj45 through wall plate. Petunia Dursley, the sister of Harry's mother, and her husband Vernon take their nephew in when his parents are murdered, raising him alongside their own son Dudley, but forcing him to live in. J.K. Rowling Reveals 'Harry Potter' Secrets About Harry's Horrible Aunt Weve seen Petunia revel in horror at the mention and sight of magic and even the fact that her sister was a witch. Maybe it even explalins why she seemed so determined to punish Harry during his magical outbursts in childhood. Petunia in the MoviesThe role of Petunia Dursley is played by Fiona Shaw (IMDb). What exactly about Aunt Petunia is "More than meets the eye"? ), Second is the charm your talking about, which Dumbledore bound to the house where Harry's mothers blood flowed and called home. Petunia had some latent feelings of guilt about the way she had cut Lily (whom she knew, in her secret heart, had always loved her) out of her life, but these were buried under considerable jealousy and bitterness. Petunia, did you want to be a witch? The Order of the Phoenix believes that Voldemort would capture and torture the Dursleys about Harry's whereabouts, so leaving Number 4 Privet Drive is their only option. What makes you think it isnt Dumbledore? The Dursleys live at number four Privet Drive, Little Whinging, Surrey. How Old Are One Direction Now? She stopped and looked back. To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers. It's addressed to Petunia and, considering the nature of Howlers, the entire household gets to hear its contents. My perfect sister being who she was. ". The reason for this estrangement actually makes a lot of sense. She is a Muggle, but [Laughter]. Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for science fiction and fantasy enthusiasts. Do Federal courts have the authority to dismiss charges brought in a Georgia Court? Hang on, was Harry Potter's Aunt Petunia actually a witch all along? PA2: Aunt Marge's Big Mistake - Harry Potter Lexicon Your aunt knows this. He could not have said why this hit him so very powerfully at this moment. And that she actually has a soul. Festive Drinks Paired With The Perfect Holiday Reads, Harlem Students Earn Reading Rewards From Vending Machine, Bookish Anomalies: 5 Books That You Wont Believe Exist, 5 Books About Greenland: Not The North Pole But Close Enough, Stephenie Meyer has Written Two Amazing YA Books, Coming Soon: John Lennons Life as a Graphic Novel. Reading through a few questions (this one in particular) I came across this quote: J. K. Rowling: Good question. Is Aunt Petunia a Witch? - Bookstr How can i reproduce the texture of this picture? Harry's aunt treated him terribly during his years living with the Dursleys, and her behavior was abusive, no matter how you look at it. However, where the Harry Potter movies left it at that, the books explained why Petunia was so cruel. Was Petunia Evans in any way magical or 100% full on Muggle abilities wise? They certainly knew about the general location of the house, wouldn't they know exactly who the residents were and where they worked? Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, and our products. We never learn what comes at the end of "She is a Muggle, but," or why her being a Squib was a "very good guess". guardian @krillgar There is. She starved and neglected him, and there were several implications of physical abuse. Why Aunt Petunia Was Good | POPSUGAR Tech He kindly responds that Petunia can't attend without magical abilities, which simply devastated her. There could be no excuse for how Petunia treated Harry throughout the Harry Potter series. ("Remember my last"?) Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for science fiction and fantasy enthusiasts. One Tumblr user (below) has concocted an exchange between Harry Potter and Aunt Petunia of how the reveal might happen, but it isnt all just wild fan desires sparking the speculation. Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. Molly Weasley had previously written to the Dursleys to ask their permission to take Harry for the summer so that he could go to the Quidditch World Cup. However, the more we read about Aunt Petunia, the better we understand why she ended up this way. How to launch a Manipulate (or a function that uses Manipulate) via a Button, Behavior of narrow straits between oceans. Aunt Petunia vowed, along with her husband Vernon, to stamp out her nephews magic. I also think there is some credence to her appreciating how dangerous and deadly Lord Voldemort was, and that she knew the entire family, including but not limited to Harry, would be endangered in turning Harry out of her home. But for my mother and father, oh no, it was Lily this and Lily that, they were proud of having a witch in the family!" Quora - A place to share knowledge and better understand the world I think maybe he was asking her to recall those memories and to extend those same decencies to Harry when Vernon wanted to wash his hands of him. No, she is not, she is not a Squib. -- Petunia to Harry (PS4). Back in 2004, JK Rowling herself teased there might be more to Aunt Petunia in response to a fan question. I thought this would refer to the bit where Petunia wanted to follow Lily (Snape's flashback showed that, right? Legend hide/show layers not working in PyQGIS standalone app. It wasnt until that awful boy the Evans familys young neighbour Severus Snape noticed Lilys burgeoning magic (she was practically flying off a garden swing at the time) that Petunia realised what her sister really was. Aunt Petunia looked as though she might faint. According to one Tumblr user, Aunt Petunia might have been a witch all along. J.K. Rowling said it was a name she and her sister used during play pretend games for "unpleasant female characters," and that she may have unconsciously picked it up from a character in an old public information film who waves at a man while he's drowning (Pm). She would not have sacrificed that pride in writing that letter to Dumbledore as a kid unless she was reasonably certain that she also had some magic in her the problem was, it just wasn't enough. Wait a moment and try again. Her final moment with Harry so nearly speaking, but falling silent speaks many volumes we will never hear. So, it clearly wasn't him. 'Let A denote/be a vertex cover'. I am being shockingly indiscreet.. Back in 2004, a fan askedJ.K. Rowlingat a book fair . Large, pale (very unlike Lily's green eyes), Tall with a long neck, "bony and horse-faced", Met her husband in an office, then became a mother and homemaker, Defeat of Voldemort; James and Lily Potter are killed, McGonagall arrives on Privet Drive in the form of a tabby cat, Petunia gets her first letter from Dumbledore, A very exciting trip to the zoo for Dudley's eleventh birthday, Harry is moved into Dudley's second bedroom, A second letter for Harry arrives in Privet Drive, A third day of the mysterious letters for Harry, A barrage of letters drives the Dursleys from their home, Uncle Vernon and Aunt Petunia treat Harry as if he doesn't exist, Harry's 13th birthday; Aunt Marge comes for a visit with the Dursleys, Dumbledore chats with the Dursleys in their living room, Albus Potter receives his father Harry's baby blanket, The Death Eaters: A Guide To Who Was Where, Albus Potter and the lesson in Quantum Mechanics, Memories in the Pensieve show Harry the true story of Snapes life and love, My Dad Didnt Strut and Neither do I!. She is a Muggle. You can read about her nerdy necessities on https://cosplayandcoffee.com/, Harry Potter: 10 Facts About Snape Left Out Of The Movies, Harry Potter: 10 Worst Things The Dursleys Have Ever Done, Harry Potter: 10 Hidden Details About House Elves You Probably Missed, Harry Potter: 10 Things You Didn't Know About Dudley Dursley. secret inside a single, living soul. No, she is not, but No, she is not a Squib. From her dealings with Dumbledore to her secret desire to be part of the magical world, here are some details about Petunia Dursley you may not know. One of the deleted scenes from Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows attempted to bring Petunia's complicated feelings to the screen. Also, however much he looks like James, he knew he can never harm someone with Lily's blood. But you will have to read the other books. .css-6owf8s{display:block;font-family:Montserrat,Helvetica,Arial,Sans-serif;font-weight:400;letter-spacing:0.025rem;margin-bottom:0;margin-top:0;-webkit-text-decoration:none;text-decoration:none;text-transform:none;}@media (any-hover: hover){.css-6owf8s:hover{color:link-hover;}}@media(max-width: 48rem){.css-6owf8s{font-size:1.125rem;line-height:1.3;}}@media(min-width: 40.625rem){.css-6owf8s{font-size:1.125rem;line-height:1.3;}}@media(min-width: 48rem){.css-6owf8s{text-align:center;}}@media(min-width: 64rem){.css-6owf8s{font-size:1.3125rem;line-height:1.2;}}First look at Sam Heughan's new thriller series, Harry Potter's Evanna Lynch ditches blonde locks, Barbie movie beats Harry Potter box office record, Harry Potter's Daniel Radcliffe shares baby update, Daniel Radcliffe shares baby son's milestone, Harry Potter star's new BBC drama gets trailer, Potter star Daniel Radcliffe confirms sex of baby, Harry Potter star's new BBC drama gets first look, Daniel Radcliffe's Miracle Workers gets s4 trailer, Potter star Bonnie Wright announces pregnancy, Harry Potter star confirms birth of first child, Stranger Things star lines up next movie role, DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK. I dont think Vernon would appreciate the magnitude of the threat posed by Voldemort. Could it be that the charms that protected Harry from Voldemort at the home of his relatives was also protecting his relatives as well? Think of it this way Petunia, for better or for worse, has a lot of pride. Which is the same spell Harry's parents used to hide from Voldemort. So he means his last action. Harry Potter: The 10 Worst Things Petunia Dursley Did To Harry, Ranked AUNT PETUNIA: Time enough. To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. However, when Lily was killed by Lord Voldemort .